In 1987, John Agrusa and Rick & Phyllis VerStrate had a dream about opening a pizza place. After working for relatives in other family owned restaurants for many years, they all combined their experience to open Sara’s Pizza in October of 1987.

John and Phyllis had their grandfather from Italy teach them to make dough, just like they do in the old Sicilian bakeries. Nonna Maria taught them how to make everything the old fashioned way, homemade spaghetti sauce, lasagna, meatballs and more!

All of our pizzas are hand tossed and made special for each customer. Not only do we use our family recipes, that have been passed through the generations, but we cook them the old fashion way in our stone ovens.

Over 33 years later, we are still a family owned and operated restaurant that has a passion of using fresh ingredients to bring great tasting Italian flavors to our customers.

Read More

To place an order:


  • FOR PICKUP: We will not be allowing any customers into the building for now. Please call, place your order, pay with credit card over the phone. Give an accurate phone number that you will be able to answer, and bring your cell phone with you. When you arrive to pick up, please call to let us know you are in the parking lot. We anticipate our business phone lines being busy, if this happens there will be a number that you can call on the window of the shop. Once we know you are there, we will bring out your order, place it on the table outside, and once our employee is out of sight, you can grab your order.
  • FOR DELIVERY: Call, place your order and pay with a credit card over the phone.  We encourage you to add a tip to the card for our drivers, as they cannot accept any tips in person. Give an accurate phone number that you will be able to answer when our driver arrives. Our driver will deliver your pizza, placing it on the front porch or by the front door. Once back in the vehicle they will call you and let you know the order has been dropped off. We will try to give an accurate delivery time, but are unable to guarantee delivery times.
Read More